Policing Issues Questionnaire for the 2020 Iowa City Police Chief Finalists
As you might have heard, following the February 24, 2020 retirement of Chief Jody Matherly, the City of Iowa City launched a recruitment process for the position of Police Chief. We are now in the final stages of this process, and also in the first and the only stage where the feedback from the public at large is accepted.
While the finalists' resumes, the Step 3 questionnaire responses, and the socially distanced “meet and greet” held by the City on August 24 in Mercer Park allowed some of us to gain more insight about the candidates, by and large, their positions on many important issues remain to be unknown.
The questionnaire below aims to bridge this gap. ICPD Watch asked all of the three Police Chief finalists to answer these questions to the degree they feel compelled to answer them.
Here are their responses:
Questions and Answers
What would be your priorities for funds allocation within the ICPD budget if the money allocated to the ICPD by the City Council were to be cut by 50%? What roles and training will you continue in the face of reduced funding, and what proactive efforts do you expect to develop?
What is your opinion on the “War on Drugs”?
What is your view on the role of the Community Police Review Board in investigating citizen complaints about police misconduct? In your opinion, should a police review board be given independent investigatory power and an authority to issue binding disciplinary action mandates?
What is your opinion on police presence in schools in general and relying on police to maintain discipline in schools in particular? Are there situations when school-based arrests for nonviolent offenses, such as disruptive behavior are warranted?
Our community is severely segregated, with the majority of poor, low-income individuals (the majority of whom are also Black) concentrated in a few neighborhoods. Under your leadership, what will the Iowa City Police Department do to alleviate the devastating effects of this segregation, reduce violence in these neighborhoods, and build better relationships with their residents?
What is your stance on citizens’ right to photograph or film the police? What are the situations when it’s appropriate to prohibit these activities? What are the situations when it’s appropriate to detain or arrest citizens engaging in these activities?
Do you believe excessive use of physical force in the day-to-day course of police encounters with citizens is a problem worth addressing? If so, how would you monitor and address this issue?
According to the 2015 St. Ambrose study, minority drivers in Iowa City were about twice as likely to be arrested during a traffic stop as were white & Asian drivers, and police officers were about twice as likely to request a voluntary search not based on probable cause from a minority driver as from others. What specific measures will you take as the police chief to address this problem?
Iowa has the fifth-worst rate of racial disparities in arrests for marijuana possession in the country. Specifically in Johnson County, a black person is about five times more likely to be arrested for drug possession than a white person, even though studies show that the two races use illicit drugs at roughly the same rates. What specific measures will you take as the police chief to address this problem?
In your opinion, should local police take part in immigration enforcement? Why?
In your opinion, should police take part in evictions? Why?
If the Iowa City Code and/or Charter were amended to ask the police to cite low-level drug offenses such as possession of small amounts of marijuana as civil infractions punishable by a fine (similarly to Section 16.2 of Ann Arbor’s City Charter), would you pursue these offenses according to the will of Iowa City residents?
What is your stance on the practice of extending traffic stops to allow for external inspection of the vehicle by a K-9 unit? How would you address a complaint that Iowa City police engage in this practice?
What’s your opinion on civil asset forfeiture? What constitutes acceptable use of civil asset forfeiture?
In your opinion, what are the responsibilities of police officers in situations involving mental illness, developmental disability, or emotionally disturbed persons?
In your opinion, what is the role of police officers with regard to the homeless population? Is there a particular framework you would apply when responding to a situation involving a homeless person?
What’s your stance on the nuisance ordinances (aka “disorderly house ordinances”) that label a property as a nuisance when it is the site of a certain number of calls for police or alleged nuisance conduct?
When police misconduct has occurred, how do you respond to the corresponding public complaint(s) and restore trust in the community?
What is your stance on police body cameras? In your opinion, what are the most important aspects of the police body cameras’ policy?
In your opinion, is police militarization a topic of concern?
Do you believe military-grade equipment such as MRAPs has a place in the police toolbox? If so, what constitutes acceptable use of such equipment (please use MRAP as an example)?
What is your opinion on no-knock warrants? What constitutes acceptable use of no-knock warrants?
What is your opinion of police surveillance of social media? What is a legitimate scenario for employing social media surveillance in police work?
What is your opinion on the use of Stingray devices (aka “cell site simulators”) and “tower dumps” in police work? What is a legitimate scenario for deploying such a device/tactic?
What’s your stance on the use of facial recognition technologies in law enforcement investigations? What is a legitimate use case for a real-time, street-ready facial recognition system? Would you pursue an implementation of such a system should the opportunity arise?
What’s your stance on the automatic traffic law enforcement devices such as red-light cameras, speed cameras, and automatic license plate recognition systems? Would you pursue an implementation of any of these technologies should the opportunity arise?
Iowa City has seen its fair share of illegal government spying on political activists. Would you make a pledge to not provide resources or any other sort of cooperation to federal agencies such as the FBI for spying on Iowa City residents that are not under active criminal investigation?
What is your stance on the police “code of silence”?
In your opinion, should activities and/or members of groups like Black Lives Matter, Occupy Wall Street, Anonymous, etc. be a subject of heightened police scrutiny? Why/why not?
In your opinion, what are acceptable crowd control tactics for containment of a citizen protest that has spilled into the streets?
In your opinion, what are the situations that call for police use of riot gear and weaponry, such as tactical vests, full-body suits, ballistic and tactical shields, batons, pepper spray, tear gas, rubber bullets, etc.?
What is your opinion on the use of Tasers and stun guns on unarmed citizens, fleeing suspects, and people who are already restrained?
A significant number of properties in downtown Iowa City are owned or controlled by the University and thus are under the jurisdiction of the UI Department of Public Safety. While officially “UI Department of Public Safety’s police officers … try to confine their patrol activities to the UI campus and routes in between numerous UI properties”, in practice the UI police officers routinely patrol Iowa City streets and have been caught in the limelight using excessive physical force and disregarding citizens’ civil rights. How do you see ideal cooperation between Iowa City police and the UI Department of Public Safety that preserves the inter-agency collaboration while adhering to the policing standards, procedures, and priorities of the Iowa City police department?
Will you adjust the department’s policies, practices, and procedures to reflect your views on the aforementioned issues?
What are the first five things you'll do if you become Iowa City’s next Chief of Police?